Maguire Family of Dealerships - Ithaca (NY)

5 /5 Trish Larter: We had the most enjoyable car buying experience at Maguire on 5/24/25 with Mark Leonard. Normally I loathe buying a new car, mostly because sales people have made me feel like a burden or a chore. Mark was a breath of fresh air from the moment we walked in. He was so kind and genuine. We never felt like we were being sold, we felt listened to and he advocated for us big time. We drove an hour and 40 minutes and drove home in the car of our dreams! If you go to Maguire, be sure to ask for Mark!

5 /5 Veronica Velez: This is my second Maguire vehicle. This time I drove 3 hours to Grand Island to buy a Hyundai Venue. I filled my application for my loan on line Jason called me on the way and by the time I arrived he had me approved and ready. My sales agent Andre was super friendly. I felt like my son was selling me a car. They were both kind enough to stay after closing hours so I didn’t have go back another day to pick up my car. I thought that was Champagne service. Thank you Jason and Andre. It was a pleasure to meet both of you. You made the long trip worthwhile.

5 /5 Judith Traxler: I can’t say enough about my day at Maguire Honda. The sales person, Jessica Bond, was outstanding. For most of the day, she helped me with the many decisions involved in buying a new car, quickly prepared the necessary paperwork, and set up Maguire’s system for my trade-in. Driving home with my new Honda CRV, I made an error and turned the power off in the middle of busy, rainy downtown traffic! I called Maguire and Jessica was there in just a few minutes, checked to be sure the car was working properly, and gave me a quick reminder of how to start and stop safely.

5 /5 Cabrina Gilbert: I was in a collision which totaled my Jeep Renegade. I wasnt in a good place to have to buy a brand new car. But Maguire on Hiawatha worked with me and got me my dream wheels! Garrett, who was new, was knowledgeable and friendly and very easy to contact and work with. Buying a car anytime is most folks nightmares. Maguire was a dream!

5 /5 sara demenkoff: Had a wonderful experience recently buying a car from sales consultant, Ryan Parker at MAGUIRE! We had an easy test drive together where he shared a wealth of knowledge about the car and was helpful and clear when it came to discussing price and financing options. He wasnt pushy in any way, just easy to talk to and kind which I did not expect. It was so refreshing! It helped that I was motivated to buy a car, but he didnt know that as I was shopping. I also didnt buy the day I did a test drive and he added no pressure as I left without buying. But I came back, in part because of talking with Ryan. A great experience all the way around. Thanks, Ryan!