Andrews Jewelers - Williamsville (NY)

michael I brought some broken family jewelry in to see if Paul could use to create a ring for my husband. He immediately drew up a rough sketch of his idea and had a rendering over to me in less than a day. His idea to inlay my broken rings into a new ring was genius and it couldn’t have turned out better. The turn around time wasn’t very long and the ring when done was more beautiful and perfect than I could have ever expected. This is the second custom ring I’ve had Paul Custom Jewelry create and they have not disappointed! Highly recommend!

Jordan Speed Made an appointment on a whim for piercings. The website/appointment booking was super easy and user friendly. Got to the shop and it was extremely clean and the staff were so knowledgeable, helpful and welcoming! Got pierced by Trevor and he was amazing! Kept us super calm and relaxed but also was just a super cool human to be around. Will definitely recommend to everyone and be going back for more piercings!

Kathryn Stroh We thought about buying my engagement ring online originally but wanted to check out local jewelers first. Once we met Ryan we knew we were going to have him design it. Everyone there is great and Ryan was so knowledgeable and helpful. Now I have my dream ring, and I’m so happy we went to a great local place.

Queen Allie Beautiful jewelry super nice staff and great deals buy one get one 50% off!!

Ambati Krishna Vamsi Reddy This place is so good and Marcus has fixed my broken chain in just 2 minutes. He even didnt charge me anything. The work was so good and he is great. Need to give a try if you have any broken gold ornaments.

Valerie Jayes We went in for my birthday gift, just to browse & see if there was anything I needed. Renee came to help me. I found a Disney necklace i needed. I started browsing rings. With Renees help, I gave her my likes & we browsed some rings & found a beauty! It was an AMAZING deal we couldnt pass up. My boyfriend is now very happy I found a promise ring I like & he got to buy me a ring. Its a pricier "promise" ring, but I am a "diamond snob" & im not upset about it!! Thank you Renee for your help!

Emanuela Scollo My now fiancee and I came here for our engagement rings. We had the most amazing shopping experience with Peter Sr. and the whole staff! As a lesbian couple we were nervous about ring shopping in general, but everyone at Ben Garelick made us feel so welcome and at home. Peter made us feel very comfortable and explained the first visit should be for trying on rings only so we could have an idea of what we liked. We didnt feel at all pressured to buy that day, and didnt purchase our rings until our second visit in the store. We both got exactly what we wanted and the rings fit our budget perfectly, and we are so happy with how the shopping and buying experience was. Our rings are absolutely beautiful and so perfectly US. We will definitely be coming back for our wedding bands. Thank you all for making this an unforgettable experience!!!

Pamela Albanese Jim was very friendly and knowledgeable. I stated I was looking for a solar powered watch. He showed me my choices. Once I picked out what I liked , Jim sized for me and made sure I was happy with the fit. The shopping experience was stress free and no pressure. Will def purely go back for more purchases!

Felix Clickenspock The friendliest most professional jewelers ! The owner is very kind & generous & the woman that works there is always a delight to talk with. Very trustworthy & I go there for all my jewelery needs & repairs. God bless them & I would highly recommend for their honesty & professionalism as well as the welcoming atmosphere.

Pat Malecki I love going to Andrews and have many years! The staff is welcoming and knowledgeable. Answers my questions and gives advice when I need it. I have always been happy w my results.