KAY Jewelers - Staten Island (NY)

Tarajee Smith My husband brought me a picture pendant from Evelyn, and it’s absolutely spectacular. The attention to detail is amazing, and the piece means so much to me. The team at Evelyn treated us like family — so warm, kind, and welcoming. It was such a great experience from start to finish. Highly recommend!

Jose Santos I recommend you coming here I just bought a silver chain and pendant on Father’s Day . Unfortunately to my surprise the stone already fell out of the cross. Here I am here five days later feeling ripped off I go in there he’s completely understanding and helps me find different pieces I can have to exchange . He worked with me and I ended up with a sterling silver bracelet and a stainless steel chain. For the same price of cross and the stainless steel piece is heavy and shines bright. Thanks Peter ill becoming back for more jewelry again

Nadine Ive known Joe and Ina for many years, from when they were in Forest Ave, flea market! They both will go out of their way to make you feel welcomed. They truly have a unique shop, lots of vintage jewelry, I think thats what drew me to them in the first place, nothing is same ole same ole. I was so happy to see theyre still in business on New Dorp Lane, since Ive been off the island for over 8 years. I travelled to them from upstate NY to get my granddaughter a piece of jewelery for her 18th birthday and graduation. As soon as I walked in Ina remembered me, we had some nice conversation and a pleasant shopping experience! As always they are 2 very fine people along with their son Gary, and Im so happy we were able to do business! Thank you so much, I will only buy from your shop. Happy to see you both, Nadine

Tammy Talluto I had an awesome experience. Mike was a pleasure to do business with. He’s honest and completely fair with his offers. You won’t be disappointed.

Risikat Ajasin The scar fade cream which now magik roots cream is the best product, I use it for just few weeks excellent result on my face. I recommend this for anybody having same issues.

Toniann Chiusano I was hesitant coming in because of the reviews but i decided to check out the shop anyway. the ladies are so sweet & honest! i recommend ❤️

Iris Holland Went in today to get my engagement ring cleaned and decide to lol at wedding bands. Your associate Sarah at the Staten Island mall was wonderful! She was extremely pleasant and kind. Showed me a few different styles and let me tried them on to see what looked best with my ring. She also gave me her honest opinion which I truly appreciated. She also noted my account with the ring that I loved. She went above and beyond and I wanted to give her the shout out she deserves! Thanks Sarah.

Paul Gargiulo Sam is a highly skilled jeweler all repairs that i brought to him were expertly repaired and in a very timely fashion. I highly recommend his facility to anyone seeking repairs or just to browse his fine selection of jewelry.

vittoria crimi I am in love with this brand! All jewlery pieces are so trendy and stylish. I love how I can combine my outfits with Libertad necklaces and bracelets. The fidget flower necklace is definitely a must have

Danny Romhen Was driving past and saw the gorgeous Rolex sign on Richmond! Decided to stop in and take a peak at the extensive inventory of beautiful watches! We were greeted at the door and walked about by the doorman who made us feel extremely welcome. Got a chance to grab a couple delicious coffees and then Samantha took us through the gorgeous Rolex models they had on display. She was extremely helpful and accommodating and I hope to do business with her at Gerald Peters soon enough!! Would highly recommend stopping in for luxury watches at any price range.