Mutual Trust Insurance Agency - Decatur (IL)

Creation By Design Smiles Winston is awesome! He covers my business , home, and life policies for me and my family. I was worried about pricing and health exams but he has several different insurance carriers he works with which gave me the best company for my circumstances. I also like that hes open to inform because I didnt know much about insurance before I switched to him. My policies arent a mystery to me anymore lol. Thanks Winston

Gabrielle Hood Great prices and always so helpful!

Cindy Cannon My husband and I have worked with Curt for probably 20 years. He is great and I would highly recommend him! He is always looking out for us.

Kyndal Gragg I recently bought a new car and called Farmers only to be met with the nicest agent (Laura). She took time to explain things to me and treated me with nothing but kindness. I totally recommend working with them. Thanks, Laura!

Erika Simmons Love their cheeseburger pizza

Aaron Rumple My experience with this insurance provider has been exceptional, warranting a five-star rating, the highest available. Despite having filed three claims across three policies within the last two years, the process has been remarkably smooth. Each claim was processed without any complications, with payments issued promptly on the same day. This company offers an unparalleled level of ease in handling claims. While the premiums may be slightly higher, the peace of mind and efficiency provided far outweigh any marginal cost increases, especially when compared to the potential difficulties of dealing with less accommodating insurance providers.

Kay Jay Had an amazing experience with Agent Erech Pierson! He contacted me almost immediately after I requested the quote, he ran the numbers and got the lowest rate for me, and he made it all so easy! I HIGHLY recommend using them if you need any kind of insurance ☺️ Thank you! -Kim Y

Mnhh Big I had an excellent experience with this insurance agency. The team was helpful in guiding me through my policy options and made sure I understood everything clearly.

Joni Vee I used Benke for commercial insurance since I purchased a building in Decatur in 2003. At first they were fine, but over time, the insurance just renewed & they provided no quote comparisons or assistance. Finally, they were acquired by AJ Gallagher & my agent Ted Miller stopped returning phone calls entirely. My premium has jumped 50% in 8 years, 25% from 2012 to 2013 alone. I have found many more eager & willing agents who have quote much lower prices & taken my business elsewhere.