19 Best Insurance Services in San Luis Obispo, CA

William J Walker Very friendly and eager to assist. Knowledgeable about products and services. I felt heard, seen and respected. Uncommonly encountered anywhere else.

Elsa It looks like going in is the better option vs calling by reading the reviews. One of the big reasons I like(d) AAA is because you talk to a person when you call. But my most recent call was disappointing because the person that picked up switched me to their AI for payment when I wanted to talk to a representative for additional questions.

Linda Poverny Even though I was upset at the home insurance industry over so many carriers leaving the CA market, Shawn took the time to explain his attempts at finding options. He made me understand I was not the only one frustrated by the home insurance situation in CA. It gave our interaction a personal touch, and a sense that he was in the customer’s corner.

Wesley Newman Shawn and Lillian have been incredibly helpful over the years, always ensuring we get the best deals on all our insurance policies. Their service has a warm, small-town feel, with excellent communication and prompt attention to keeping our policies up-to-date. Minton Insurance truly goes above and beyond—thank you for your outstanding service!

Stephanie Fitz-Gerald Weve had the pleasure of working with McGee Insurance and their team for over a decade. We couldnt be more satisfied with the level of service and dedication theyve consistently provided. A special thank you to Genie-Rose for her thoughtful recommendations and professional responses to my never ending questions! Its clear they genuinely care about their clients, and that level of personal service is rare. We highly recommend McGee Insurance Agency to any business or individual looking for a trusted, long-term insurance partner. ~Stephanie Fitz-Gerald/Alpha Electrical Service

CLSC Barbara Aldana was extremely helpful in finding homeowners insurance policies for me, which is no easy task after all the fires in California! She was knowledgeable, professional, friendly and efficient. I highly recommend using her for any insurance needs!

Gabriel Erno I started working with the Meredith insurance in my early 20’s. I was overwhelmed by the prospect of finding my own health insurance. The Meredith insurance center made it easy and stress free. Amy is extremely professional, knowledgable, and will listen to your needs. I would highly recommend using their services.

allison rice I am so glad my friend referred me to Meredith Insurance Center. I have a much better plan and MUCH better rates! Amy was so helpful and really knows her stuff. I think most people dont know how to navigate insurance companies and even the employees at Blue Shield and Covered California dont have all the knowledge. Amy just changed my life. For real. The money I am saving will now go into my savings accounts! Thank you.

Lizeth Hernandez Rachel found me better coverage and saved me money. Affordable princing and great communication

Marcelo Tanaka Dave is a great person and professional, recommend to anyone in search for insurance.

Marsha Richardson I like everything about Legends and the very kind personnel I spoke with on the phone very recently! Very compassionate, easy to speak with, & didnt overwhelm me with too many facts all at once, gave me time and freedom to share my concerns, and helped me feel safe to tell the truth about my medical conditions. Telling the truth is very important to me & at the same time felt the freedom to share it without fear of judgement, even if I was turned down for coverage, which I was NOT. They helped me understand the facts, and listened to ALL my concerns. I would HIGHLY recommend Legends United Insurance for your life insurance, burial needs, etc. & any other type of insurance you might need especially during these very difficult times we are living in! I also have no other ulterior motives for sharing this information, except that that was my personal experience recently and would not hesitate to share it from that perspective and will continue to recommend Legends to everyone I know and come in contact with day to day. Sincerely, Marsha Richardson

Singh Bruce (5 Star Electric) Debbie, Sharon and Rowland are some of my favorite people to work with. I can always count on this team to help me resolve my business issues. I strongly recommend this company and we will continue using them! Thank you!

and Jeremy Jeff Anyone who tries to get the best price and coverage is doing themselves a disservice when Britney will do the work for you. Was recommended by my lender, I cant believe everyone does not use this service, she is the cheat code for Californias terrible insurance climate!

Paul Masters This guy Arrow Grantham and his trusted business partner Brittney Palmer go the extra mile when the cards are down. They stepped up to the plate and assisted with the most exhausting claims when the corporate monster insurance company had led me astray with the most taxing circumstance of my life involving the destruction of an insured rental property. They are truly relational and will help you beyond the widlest call of duty to help you when your barn is truly burning in life and you have nowhere else to turn. Thanks Arrow and Brittney!

Atlas Jude The specialist from Roberts & Stavich was patient and really buckled down for me to get the right protection for my prerequisites. I would prescribe him to anybody. I have attempted so often previously however specialist was the main one to sort it for me, superb work.

Jamie Bales They have always been prompt, professional, and extremely helpful in answering all of my questions about my insurance policy and getting me what I needed. Thank you once more.

Philip Wahl Tina is extremely unprofessional and incompetent. She has been sending me emails for over a year that contain information pertaining to another client. I have asked many times to be removed from the email chain and still nothing. Beyond incompetent and unprofessional! Avoid dealing with Tina if you value the safe keeping of your personal information!

Heidi Sealy Tina Donaldson is a first rate professional who provides outstanding customer service. She is extremely knowledgeable of the nuances of the complicated insurance market; and just as important, she is timely and responsive in how she manages client questions and requests. She has removed all the angst and uncertainty we had about our insurance coverages. We are thrilled to have been introduced to Tina through an acquaintance and would refer her to anyone who is looking for a seasoned professional who knows what to do and how to do it.

C. Scott Went to budget cafe next door to this gem. had to sit outdoor due to corona virus guidelines. Got to enjoy this business complain through our entire meal about how the cafe was taking up parking spaces for dining...(3 spaces were blocked off). Apparently the cafe had cause their booming insurance business to decline to nothing. Totally unprofessional and unreasonable to the times we are in. Wouldnt recommend anyone go there based on basic human decency.

Jessica Stvincent Been with them for almost 10 years. Super friendly and professional. They know me by first name. I would recommend them to anyone who likes to save money without sacrificing service.

T K LEMAY Amazing customer service for my family for over 40 years. You needn’t look any further. These amazing people are friendly and really care about your families welfare being fair to all parties! Quick easy and always a win win for all involved! Cheers Engle family!!

Olivia Radovich Cameron A. at Engle & Associates was so helpful in coordinating a refund owed to us by an insurance company. We greatly appreciate the time he took and the back and forth communication that was made. I highly recommend Engle & Associates. They really helped out our small business.

Chela GEM Olivia is awesome! We have been with her for years and when she moved from the paso location to Slo and opened her own business we had to follow her ! She’s good at explaining everything and is always there for us if we have questions.

Steven Anglin I am so glad im in good hands. I got into an Accident allstate is the best insurance that ive ever had. Are you in good hands.

Andrew Eastham Mike Smith took over when my State Farm agent of many years retired. He and his staff have been helpful and friendly. Yvonne Gray in particular went above and beyond by personally photographing the roof of my house in S.L.O. when that was necessary to address concerns and I was out of state and unable to do so.

Elijah D I’ve been a customer of Victoria Pollock since 2021, and she has consistently gone above and beyond to provide excellent service. She’s always friendly, knowledgeable, and quick to answer any questions I have. Whether it’s explaining coverage details or helping with policy changes, Victoria makes the process smooth and stress-free. I truly appreciate her professionalism and dedication — I wouldn’t want to work with anyone else for my insurance needs! – Elijah Del Valle

Marlene Smith Catherine has been the best insurance agent I’ve honestly ever had. From the subtle kind gesture of sending me delicious cookies after becoming my agent from day 1, to helping me through a claim that happened on private property & holding my hand through it all as my first incident to being an overall amazing agent by keeping me well informed & her honesty. She never hesitated to be there when I needed her, had questions or needed answers or something fully explained-she was there to make sure I fully understood policies & she does it with patience & great customer service. You can tell she truly cares about her clients & her efforts show! Unfortunately State Farm raised the prices in Jan 2025 for California & Oregon, which increased my monthly premium nearly $50 & it was already at $300 a month for full coverage auto & renters bundle. I was doing what I could to keep my agent, however found another insurance that offered the same premium, coverage & deductible for $150 less at $210 a month & I could not refuse financially. This has been one of the hardest things for me to adjust to, as I already Miss Catherine & my State Farm customer service. Financially though, I couldn’t justify it. I sure do hope I can return at a later time & get Catherine back. She’s amazing.

Amy Blalock Catherine and her team are honest and knowledgeable. I have been with them since I moved to town 5 years ago. Catherine always ensures I get the best rate and proper coverage. I always feel she has my best interest in mind. She takes the time to answer all my questions never making me feel rushed or unheard. I trust Catherine and her office staff. There is no better Insurance Agent in SLO.

Spencer Omberg Have been with the Wright agency for over 16 years. Service has continually gone down hill since Josh took over from his father Michael. Lately, messages left arent returned. The agency no longer provides the service they once did.

Nancy Jackson We have been customers of the Wright/Farmers Insurance office for the past 33 years. They continue to fulfill our auto and homeowners insurance needs. It is so nice to speak to our local agent (Joshua Wright) and his staff whenever a question comes up. They really know us and care about us. Dana is especially kind and knowledgeable with details of our coverage. They all help us to find the best and most affordable coverage available.